On October 12th, 2012, 28-year-old Ryan Poston, a successful attorney from Kentucky was found dead, shot 6 times in his condo. He’d been shot to death by his girlfriend Shayna Hubers. According to Shayna, she wasn’t some sort of cold-blooded killer. She said she shot him out of self-defense. It was either kill or be killed.

After a bizarre police interrogation, Shayna was arrested and charged with Ryan’s murder. At trial, it came down to whether you believed the prosecution’s star forensic expert, or the defense’s expert.

It became a story known as the “Nose Job Murder”. A Jodi Arias Copycat. A murder that would be forever talked about.